Natural Science Seminar
Abstracts - Spring 2005
Abigail Miner
January 31, 2005
The effects of
Stekoa Creek on the water quality of the Chattooga River
Mentor: Dr. Mark Brenner
Abstract: The Chattooga River
is located on the border of northeast Georgia and northwest South
Carolina. It is a federally designated Wild and Scenic River and
it is known for its stunning natural beauty, challenging whitewater and
generally good water quality. Stekoa Creek flows into the lower
part of the Chattooga River and is a potential threat to the water
quality of the Chattooga. The objective of this study was
to determine the effect of Stekoa Creek on the health of the Chattooga
River by comparing the water quality upstream and downstream of the
confluence of the two waterways. Biochemical oxygen demand
(B.O.D.) , total suspended solids (T.S.S.), ammonia (NH3), and
fecal coliform tests were preformed. Samples were collected from three
sites on five dates. For fecal coliform, B.O.D. and T.S.S.
testing, established methods were used as described in the Standard
Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater. For ammonia
testing, the Hach-Nessler variation on the standard methods was
used. All results were analyzed with a repeated measures
A.N.O.V.A. No significant variation between sites was found for
B.O.D, T.S.S. and NH3, with P values of 0.6883, 0.1579 and 0.7863
respectively. For fecal coliforms, the variation between all
three sites was found to be extremely significant with a P <
0.0001. While NH3, T.S.S. and B.O.D. all indicated
generally good water quality, these data indicate that Stekoa Creek is
detrimentally affecting the fecal coliform levels of the Chattooga
river. One probable source is primitive septic systems in the
Stekoa Creek watershed, along with a leaky sewer infrastructure in the
town of Clayton, Ga.
James Stultz
Factors
Contributing to Ciguatera Toxicity in Bahamian Barracudas
January 31, 2005
Mentor Dr. Paul Bartels
Ciguatera fish poisoning is the most common
marine seafood toxin disease worldwide. Ciguatera is a form of
poison that is caused by the consumption of large carnivorous
fish. At least 50,000 to 500,000 people per year suffer from
ciguatera poisoning, and cases are largely confined to tropical and
subtropical areas. Ciguatera poisoning comes from a toxin
produced by the dinoflagellate Gambierdiscus toxicus. In the
Caribbean, fish toxicity appears to increase with the size of the
fish. Herbivorous reef fish introduce ciguatera into the food
chain by ingesting the toxic dinoflagellates G. toxicus. The
toxins are then transferred to carnivorous fish where they are
concentrated in the flesh and viscera. The objective of this
study was to determine if location, size, and the presence of external
parasites could be used to accurately predict ciguatera toxicity in
Bahamian barracudas. The study was conducted in the Atlantic
Ocean off the coast of Florida and throughout the Bahamas islands, and
data was collected from the 22nd of May through the 4th of June.
During the sampling period, 22 samples were obtained and all samples
were used in analysis. Correlation analysis was used to detect
any significant correlation between toxicity and the distance to shore,
distance to reef, distance to shelf, water depth, length, and
weight. The p-value for each of the variables were as follows;
toxicity vs. distance to shore 0.0780, toxicity vs. distance to reef
0.5706, toxicity vs. distance to shelf 0.2311, toxicity vs. water depth
0.2999, toxicity vs. length 0.1120, and toxicity vs. weight
0.0105. A t-test was used to determine if there was any
significant difference between toxicity and the presence of external
parasites. The p-value was 0.9326. An ANOVA test was used
to see if there was any significant difference between toxicity and the
different island groups. The p-value was 0.9862. Of all the
variables tested, weight was the only variable that had a p-value low
enough to suggest that weight had a strong correlation to
toxicity. Most locals believe that the presence of external
parasites could be used in predicting toxicity among barracudas.
My results do not support the hypothesis of using parasites to predict
toxicity among barracudas. The data also suggest no difference
between toxicity and where each fish was caught.
Erin K. McVey
February 7, 2005
Heavy Metals in
American Alligator (Alligator
mississippiensis) Eggshells from Three
Florida Lakes
Mentor: Dr. John Brock
Abstract: For the past
decade, scientists have turned to synthetic pesticides to explain the
morphological abnormalities, altered hormone levels, and decreased egg
viability rates of Florida’s American alligators (Alligator
mississippiensis). No studies have looked at the presence of
metals in American alligator eggshells. Heavy metals have an
affinity for reproductive organs and overexposure can lead to
toxicity. Eggshells have been shown to provide another method for
excreting metals from the body.
Three eggs were collected from five different nests
on Lake Woodruff, Lake Apopka, and Lake Griffin. Approximately
fifteen eggs were collected from each lake. Lake Woodruff
was used as the control lake in this study; Lake Griffin and Lake
Apopka were not. An Inductively Coupled Plasma Spectrometer (ICP)
was used to measure the concentration of heavy metal ions in American
alligator eggshells.
Detectable levels of six heavy metal ions were
measured in American alligator eggshells. The p-values obtained
from a one-way ANOVA variance test determined that there was not a
significant difference in the concentration of the metal ion, in the
eggshells, between the three lakes. The r2 values and p-values
obtained from the correlation analysis showed no correlation between
the metal concentrations in the eggshells and the egg viability rates
specific to each lake.
ANOVA one-way variance
results
|
Metal
|
Type of Test
|
p-value
|
|
Cd
|
non-parametric
|
0.5236
|
|
Cr
|
non-parametric
|
0.3619
|
|
Fe
|
parametric
|
0.1419
|
|
Mg
|
non-parametric
|
0.2777
|
|
Mn
|
parametric
|
0.9807
|
|
Ni
|
parametric
|
0.2048
|
Correlation analysis results
|
Metal
|
r2
|
p-value
|
|
Cd
|
0.04821
|
0.8591
|
|
Cr
|
0.5418
|
0.4733
|
|
Fe
|
0.5404
|
0.4743
|
|
Mg
|
0.6475
|
0.4047
|
|
Mn
|
0.3853
|
0.9937
|
|
Ni
|
0.9875
|
0.0714*
|
These data do not support the hypothesis that heavy metals affect egg
viability.
Maureen
McKenna
February 14, 2005
Monitoring
Beneficial Insectary Habitats on a Certified, Organic, Mixed-Vegetable
Farm
Mentor: Dr. Laura Lengnick
Abstract: Organic farmers must
find alternative methods of crop pest management because certification
requirements prelude the use of chemical insecticides. John
Rowland, owner of ‘R’ Farm – a certified organic vegetable farm in
Weaverville, NC, has been practicing a method of pest control called
farmscaping. Rowland plants beneficial insectary habitats of
annual flowers or herbs in bed-row ends in order to encourage
populations of beneficial insects that are predators or parasitoids of
insect pests. The objective of this study was to determine the
success of the various insectary plants in attracting beneficial
insects and not providing harborage for pest species. The design
of the plots mirrored that of Rowland’s as closely as possible.
Data were collected using an observational technique in which the
frequency of visits to the flower by beneficial or pest arthropods was
recorded. Data analysis required that all the insects be
identified and classified into functional groups as beneficial, pest,
or unknown. Bishop’s flower was found to have significantly more
visits from beneficial insects than either calendula or buckwheat
(p-value = 0.000 in both cases). The literature supports the
finding that bishop’s flower is a good insectary plant, but suggests
that buckwheat should be an appropriate choice as well. In
further investigation, it was found that buckwheat was being observed
at the wrong time of day in order to monitor beneficial insect
activity. Calendula was shown to have significantly more visits
from pest insects than bishop’s flower (p-value = 0.013).
Calendula’s high pest visitation frequency resulted from a black
blister beetle invasion during three dates in late August and was
probably the result of a nearby farms alfalfa harvest. Future
study of Calendula and buckwheat are needed to determine their
effectiveness as beneficial insectary plants. Bishop’s flower was
found to be a good plant to use in order to attract beneficial insects.
Laurel E. Key
February 14, 2005
Prescribed burning
effects on the density and diversity of small vertebrates at Jones
Mountain
Mentor: Dr. Louise Weber
Abstract: Prescribed burning
is
a mechanism used to prevent wildfires and control invasive
species.
However, studies in other habitats have found that fire can alter
species density and diversity. My objective was to determine
whether
prescribed burning is having a detrimental effect on small vertebrates
at Jones Mountain, Buncombe County, NC. I conducted a 40 day
mark-recapture study on burned and unburned areas using the Schnabel
method for continuous mark-recapture. Population density was
estimated
to be 31 small mammals on the burn side of the W.C. Davis Stand between
Sept. 4 and Dec. 4, 2004. On the unburned side, population
density was
estimated to be 58 small mammals. No salamanders were
caught. The
primary small mammal taxa were white-footed mice (Peromyscus leucopus),
52 of 53 total small mammals caught. With more replication, my
results
would imply that small mammal population density in unburned areas on
Jones Mountain is almost twice that of burned areas. This
suggests
that small mammals, primarily white-footed mice, prefer unburned forest
stands, making it vital to preserve this habitat and study small
mammals closely following burns.
Irene
Redmond
February 6, 2005
The Effects of
Agriculture on the Water Quality and the Invertebrate
Communities of Shope and Bull Creeks
Mentor: Dr. Mark Brenner
Abstract: Non point source
(NPS) pollution from agriculture is a major cause of water pollution in
the United States. Five sites in an agricultural watershed along Shope
and Bull Creeks in Buncombe County, N. C. were sampled over four dates
in the fall and winter of 2004. Samples were analyzed for total
suspended solids (TSS), biochemical oxygen demand (BOD), and
invertebrate sampling was done once at the furthest upstream and
downstream sites to determine the effects of one farm on the water
quality of Shope and Bull Creeks. The data were analyzed using a
repeated measures ANOVA statistical test. The p-value for TSS was
0.5749 and the p-value for BOD was 0.6127. I cannot conclude that there
is a significant difference in the concentration of these parameters
between sites. The invertebrate composition included all the same taxa
upstream and downstream except one invertebrate that was only found in
the headwaters, Order Diptera, Family Tipulidae, the crane fly. The
results suggest that there is no evidence to support the claim that
this farm is polluting the water for the parameters I tested.
Ryan M. Tarbell
February 21, 2005
Instinctive
Archery: A Study of the Aiming Process
Mentor: Dr. Mark Brenner
Abstract: The origin of archery
is over 12,000 years old, and since that time every race and nation has
used some form of the bow and arrow. Barebow shooting is defined
as shooting the bow and arrow without any external sighting device, but
many forms of barebow shooting use reference points on the arrow, bow,
or bow hand that aid in the aiming process. Instinctive shooting
is a form of barebow shooting that uses no conscious reference
points. It is widely debated if instinctive shooting uses
subconscious reference points, and no studies have been conducted on
the matter. The objective of this study is to determine if
archers claiming to be instinctive shooters actually use any type of
reference point while shooting instinctively. Six archers
identifying themselves as instinctive shooters and three barebow
shooters who stated they consciously use reference points shot ten
arrows at a red laser dot from fifteen meters in normal lighted
conditions and in complete darkness. The distance of each arrow
from the bulls eye was recorded for each test group. The ten
shots in each test group were used to run an unpaired Welch corrected
t-test for each archer. All archers had a p-value of less than
0.05 except one archer that used reference points with a p- value of
0.077. The data strongly suggests that instinctive shooters are
using subconscious reference points. The shooters in this study
may not truly be instinctive shooters, or instinctive shooters may use
subconscious reference points.
David V. Tormey
February 28, 2005
Nitrogen release
by alfalfa (Medicago sativa) and corn (Zea mays) crop residues
Mentors: Dr. Mark Brenner and Dr. Laura Lengnick
Abstract: Nitrogen is the
most common limiting nutrient in crop production. Both synthetic
nitrogen fertilizers and fixation of nitrogen in root nodules of
legumes can contribute to providing sufficient nitrogen to crop
production. Crop rotations that include a legume crop that fix
sufficient nitrogen decrease the need for applied synthetic nitrogen
fertilizers. The purpose of this study was to determine the
useable nitrogen levels in a Warren Wilson College Farm field soil
after a rotation of two years of alfalfa and after a year of
corn. Soil samples were collected from the Big Bottom field in
the spring after the alfalfa/legume mix had been tilled and in the fall
after the corn had been tilled. Three sample dates were collected
10-12 days apart after both crops were tilled. The samples were
analyzed for both NH4+ and NO3- using methods found in the HACH
spectrophotometer manual. A repeated measures ANOVA was used to
analyze the results. There was a significant increase in NO3-
over the three sample dates (P < 0.0001) after the alfalfa was
tilled. The NH4+ values after the alfalfa was tilled showed no
significant difference. Significant differences were found for
both NH4+ (P < 0.0352) and NO3- (P < 0.0079) after the corn was
tilled. These results show a strong change in NO3- after
the alfalfa was tilled as well as a significant change in NO3-
after the corn was tilled. These significant but different levels
of increase are due to the warm and cold temperatures at the time of
sampling and the high and low amounts of nitrogen in the two different
crop residues.
Kristal Dawn
McKelvey
February 28, 2005
Community
Structure of Aquatic Tardigrades in Cades Cove – Great Smoky Mountains
National Park
Mentors: Dr. Paul Bartels and Dr. Mark Brenner
Abstract: Tardigrades are a
major component of the meiofaunal community and are believed to be
important in trophic webs, yet little is known about their ecology, and
this is especially true of freshwater tardigrades. The All Taxa
Biodiversity Inventory (ATBI) is a biological initiative to identify
every organism in the Great Smoky Mountains National Park (GSMNP) and
tardigrades are being studied as part of this initiative. Abrams Creek
in the Cades Cove area of the GSMNP is of particular interest because
it has not been surveyed for tardigrades and it has underlying
limestone geology, which is rare in the Appalachian Mountains.
Limestone aquatic systems are generally high in biological productivity
due to high alkalinity and water hardness. The objective of this study
was to identify the aquatic tardigrade species present in Abrams Creek
to add to the ATBI, and to evaluate the diversity and similarity of
tardigrade communities in three sites of the unique Cades Cove
watershed. Four periphyton and four sediment samples were
collected at each of three sites: upstream of the limestone area,
a limestone spring, and immediately downstream of the limestone area.
These samples were preserved, concentrated, and then examined for
tardigrades using a dissecting microscope. Each tardigrade was
mounted on a slide and identified to the species level using phase
contrast microscopy. A total of 306 specimens were
identified. Twenty-five different tardigrade species were found,
seven of which were new to the ATBI collection. The aquatic
section of the ATBI database now has 31 total aquatic species.
The statistical program EstimateS 7.0 was used to calculate similarity
and diversity. Tardigrades in sediment were very patchy ranging from
only 2-5 species, while periphyton tardigrades were diverse ranging
from 12-18 species. The Abundance-Based Coverage Estimator in
EstimateS 7.0 estimated total species levels to be 17 ± 1.07
upstream, 19.02 ± 1.31 in the spring, and 22.72
± 5.75 downstream for periphyton samples. The Bray-Curtis
similarity index was calculated between the different sites with the
downstream site and the upstream site having the lowest similarity at
0.341 and the limestone sites, spring and downstream having the highest
similarity at 0.5. Seven of the 25 species found were new records
for the Smokies. Five may be new to science, and three are new to
North America. A second set of samples was collected in December
2004 and it will be evaluated this semester to further delineate the
ecological uniqueness of the Abrams Creek watershed. My data
suggests that there are unique tardigrade species in the Cades Cove
area and there may be increased diversity with increased limestone
exposure.
Rebecca
Rudicell
March 7, 2005
The environmental
fate of dibutyl phthalate in a freshwater system with zebrafish (Danio rerio) embryos
Mentor: Dr. John Brock
Abstract: Dibutyl phthalate
(DBP) is a known developmental toxin and an endocrine active
compound. Researchers at Warren Wilson College have previously
examined DBP exposure and zebrafish (Danio rerio): Ferguson (2002)
determined DBP to be toxic to zebrafish embryos; Stokes (2002)
determined the LD50 for zebrafish embryos to be 2.4 ppm; and Lucas
(2004) determined the LD50 to be 53 ppm. These studies did not
examine the distribution of DBP within the experimental system.
How much DBP actually partitions into the eggs? The objective of
this study was to determine the environmental distribution of DBP is a
mock-freshwater system with zebrafish eggs and to determine the
partitioning coefficient between the eggs and water. Zebrafish
eggs were collected daily and exposed to one of four treatments: 1.54
ppm DBP, 3.37 ppm DBP, 4.67 ppm DBP, and a methanol control.
Another treatment set was performed in the same manner, without
eggs. Samples were analyzed using solid phase extraction (SPE)
and gas chromatography with flame ionization detection (GC-FID).
Dimethyl phthalate (DMP) was used as an internal standard. Each
day’s data were calibrated with a known standard and adjusted for
percent recovery from the SPE. The only statistically significant
difference of note between treatments groups was between 1.54 ppm with
eggs and 1.54 ppm without eggs (P<0.01). On average, 36.92
± 17.42 % of the DBP was either absorbed or metabolized by the
eggs, 55.53 ± 16.07 % of DBP remained in the water as the parent
compound, and 7.55 ± 15.69 % of DBP was lost to other
sources. Correcting for the number of eggs in each sample did not
decrease the high variability of the data. In this study, Kegg
was determined to be 113 ± 70. DBP partitioned into the
eggs at concentrations 113 times greater then the concentration of DBP
in the surrounding water. Log(Kegg) was determined to be 2.06
± 0.27. Log(Kegg) was much lower than the reported values
of log(Kiso), 3.7, 4.45, and 4.72. DBP partitioned into the
eggs 100+ times less then it would partition into isooctane, possibly
suggesting the presence of water within the egg or a barrier that
limits DBP absorption by the egg.
Patty Baxter
March 7, 2005
Little Brown Bat
habitat and inhabitation of bat boxes on Warren Wilson Campus
Mentor: Dr. Lou Weber
Abstract: There is a
population of Little Brown Bats (Myotis lucifugus) on the Warren Wilson
College Campus, and very little is known about this population. A way
to be able to study and learn more about this population is to have
them in a place where you can observe them, and this can be done by
putting up bat boxes. This study is what will start introducing Little
Brown Bats to campus in places where they are easily accessible to
students and the general public. The objective of this study was to
define the distribution of and define the habitats of Little Brown Bats
on the Warren Wilson College Campus. The methods used in this study
were observation of the population of bats in the bat houses, and the
Weber Qualitative Habitat Assessment for forest. Overall no bats
inhabited the bat houses on the dates that were observed. The Warren
Wilson College Campus has all the aspects to support a population of
Little Brown Bats. The college has some roosting sites, as well as some
good foraging sites for them. The college has aspects such as still
water sources, patchy forests, older stands, and a mixed forest matrix.
The college could be a place to educate the public about what a bat
actually does, and how helpful they are.
Saba Alemayehu
March 28, 2005
The Effect of pH
on the survival of the aquatic Tardigrade Hypsibius dujardini
Mentors: Dr. Paul Bartels and Dr. John Brock
Abstract: Tardigrades are a
major component of the meiofaunal community, yet little is known about
their habitat requirements or ecological tolerances, particularly
regarding pH. Acidification of streams, due to acid rain, has been
shown to lead to elimination of some aquatic organisms, which in turn
can lead to a loss of biodiversity. Distribution patterns of some
tardigrade species are known to be affected by pH. The Great Smoky
Mountains National Park (GSMNP) has been shown to be one of the most
polluted National Parks in the Untied States, due to a heavy effect of
air pollution. In turn, the streams in the GSMNP have also been
affected by the increase of acid rain. Hypsibius dujardini is a common
species found in the GSMNP. A direct study of the effect of pH on
the survival of tardigrades has not been published. The first objective
of this study was to determine the effect of pH on the survival of the
aquatic tardigrade Hypsibius dujardini using a broad pH range from pH
7-2 and then using a more specific pH range from pH 3-2. The second
objective of this study was to examine the effects by long term
exposure to pH 4 and pH 3 on the aquatic tardigrade Hypsibius
dujardini. Hypsibius dujardini was cultured in small dishes containing
algae as food source. In the first experiment these tardigrades
were run through a short term (5 minute) protocol using a pH range from
7-2, then again using a pH range from 3-2. Another experiment was
performed by exposing Hypsibius dujardini to a long term (30 hour)
treatment of pH 4 and pH 3. The results in the first experiment
showed that there was a significant difference in activity at pH 3 and
no tardigrades survived at pH 2.8. The results of the second experiment
showed that there was a significant drop in activity after 10 minutes
at pH 3 and also after 1 hour at pH 4; at pH 3 all specimens became
inactive after 20 minutes. These results demonstrate that the activity
of tardigrades can be affected by short term exposure at pH 3 and by
long term exposure at pH 4. The lowest pH recorded in the GSMNP is 4.2
and this is very near the level that I’ve shown to be detrimental.
Valerie
Bartell
April 4, 2005
Kombucha tea and
the risk of pathogenic contaminants in home-brew cultures
Mentor: Dr. Jeffery Holmes
Abstract: Kombucha tea is an
ancient home remedy originating in Asia that is produced by the
fermentation of sugared black tea with a symbiotic culture of yeast and
bacteria. In general, the bacteria belong to the genus
Acetobacter, but the species of
yeast are more variable. The tea has been claimed to have many
therapeutic affects, but the FDA cautions that home-brewed cultures
grown in non-sterile conditions could contain pathogenic contaminants.
The objective of this study was to assess the risk of contamination
with such potential pathogens as
Escherichia
coli and
Candida albicans
in Kombucha tea. Kombucha cultures were prepared with black tea (0.35%
w/v) and cane sugar (6.8% w/v) using a commercial starter culture and
10% by volume of previously fermented tea. Samples of the Kombucha tea
were taken between fermentation days 1-14 and used in an agar diffusion
assay with
E. coli and
C. albicans. The antimicrobial
activity of Kombucha tea against
E.
coli increased with fermentation time, while no inhibition was
observed for
C. albicans. A
second assay measured the survival of
E.
coli and
C. albicans
(separately) in the fermenting tea. Both microorganisms were seen to
grow in plain sugared black tea and decline in population when added to
K-tea. The concentration of
E. coli
declined rapidly to zero between 6 and 48 hrs. The concentration of
C. albicans declined more gradually
and reached zero on the 9th day of fermentation. The rate of inhibition
varied between cultures, but in each the degree of inhibition increased
with fermentation time. Increased inhibition is partly due to a
decrease in pH but also possibly to an increase in metabolites from the
black tea. It can be concluded that with these Kombucha tea cultures
the risk of contamination with
E.
coli and
C. albicans
is relatively low and decreases with increased fermentation.
However, there is still a potential risk of contamination with other
pathogenic organisms not focused on in this study.
Tom Hughes
April 11, 2005
Potential for
biogas production from two exotic, invasive plant species, Kudzu (Pueraria montana) and Japanese
Honeysuckle (Lonicera japonica)
Mentor: Dr. Mark Brenner
Abstract: Anaerobic digestion
is a process during which a consortium of bacterial species degrade
organic material in the absence of oxygen, producing as a product a
mixture of methane and carbon dioxide known as biogas. Due to the
similarities between biogas and fossil-derived natural gas, recent
research has focused on optimizing the anaerobic digestion process for
the conversion of plant feedstocks to biogas for use as an alternative
fuel. Plant species from over 100 genera have been evaluated as
feedstocks for biogas production. The objective of this study was to
evaluate two species of exotic invasive plants common in the
southeastern United States, Kudzu and Japanese Honeysuckle, as
feedstocks for biogas production. A biochemical methane potential (BMP)
assay was used. Feedstock samples were combined with a defined media
and bacterial inoculum and incubated until gas production ceased. Mean
ultimate gas yields (liters of gas per gram volatile solids added)
after 60 days of digestion were 0.39, 0.32 and 0.49 for Kudzu,
Japanese Honeysuckle and a cellulose positive control, respectively. A
non-parametric ANOVA was used to compare these yields. There was no
significant difference between treatments (p=0.1679) suggesting that
both species have a potential biogas yield similar to that of pure
cellulose. While the invasive characteristics of these species preclude
their use as cultivated energy crops, their relatively high
biodegradabilities as well as the fact that current management
strategies involve removal may make them ideal feedstocks for biogas
production.
Jesse E.
Downs
April 18, 2005
The effect of a
pasture supplemented diet on lipid oxidation in pork
Mentor: Dr. Victoria Collins
Abstract: This study
investigated the effect of a pasture supplemented diet on lipid
oxidative stability in pork. This is a standard test of meat
quality. Two groups of hogs were raised – one group was farrowed
indoors and raised outside on a bare soil lot (pasture - ). The
other group was farrowed outdoors on pasture and remained on pasture
until time of slaughter (pasture +). The pigs were fed the same
diet, ad libitum, consisting of corn, soybean meal (SBM) and a
vitamin-mineral supplement. Hogs were slaughtered at
approximately six and a half months of age and an average live weight
of approximately 130 kg. Ground pork (2:1 meat/fat) from 18 hogs
in each group was analyzed for the lipid oxidation product
malondialdehyde (MDA) using the thiobarbituric acid reactive substances
(TBARS) test after 1, 3, 8, and 16 days of refrigerated storage.
The product of this reaction was quantified using spectrophotometry at
534.15 nm. Mean MDA concentrations for each group on each day
were compared using an unpaired t-test assuming unequal variance.
The meat from the pasture (+) group was found to have higher initial
oxidation (days 1 and 3), but at days 8 and 16 the pasture (–) group
tended to have higher oxidation. The oxidation of the pasture (+)
pork was eclipsed by that of the pasture (-) pork at approximately 6
days of storage.
Charlotte
Litjens
Hydrolytic
degradation of polycarbonate beverage containers and migration of
bisphenol A into liquids
Mentor Dr. Dean C. Kahl
April 25, 2005
Abstract: Bisphenol A (BPA) is
a monomer involved in the formation of polycarbonate plastics, and has
been documented as an endocrine active compound in several reports in
the literature. Migration of bisphenol A from polycarbonate beverage
containers due to hydrolysis of polymers has also been shown in the
literature. The objectives of this research were to develop a method to
measure bisphenol A, in order to determine the degree to which
bisphenol A migrates from polycarbonate water bottles. Cut portions
from Nalgene® brand polycarbonate water bottles were exposed to hot
water, cold water, hot isooctane, and cold isooctane. Isooctane was
chosen to simulate fatty liquids based on reports in literature showing
the same migration results for monomers of other plastics into
isooctane and fatty foods. An internal standard was used for
quantitation. Test liquids were analyzed for the presence of BPA having
migrated from polycarbonate using gas chromatography/mass spectroscopy
in the Selective Ion Monitoring (SIM) mode. In the first experiment, no
detectable BPA was present in water or isooctane at a concentration
higher than 9 ppm. In a second experiment, out of twenty samples, four
had bisphenol A present. A water blank treated in the oven had a
concentration of 40 ppb BPA, suggesting contamination. The same samples
were analyzed using GC/MS again, showing no detectable BPA. The model
of exposure used in this experiment was a 3- fold exaggeration of
normal bottle use according to surface area to volume ratios. The
results of this study differ from published results regarding baby
bottles and prepared PC samples, suggesting that Nalgene® water
bottles may be safer for drinking. Long-term research should be
conducted to test extended use and aging of this type of polycarbonate.